Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare

Amber Lleida , Linda Greening

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePoster

    Abstract

    Concern has been raised to the welfare of carriage pulling horses in terms of breeds used, the occurrence of lameness, poor body condition, the effects of heat and environmental stressors. There is also weak legislation surrounding the regulation of carriage horses. The aim of this study was to identify the Bahamian publics perception of welfare of carriage horses used for tourism in The Bahamas. Objectives included determining the Bahamian publics understanding of welfare and welfare needs, and whether perceptions were influenced by level of education or experience with horses. An online questionnaire made available via Survey monkey was completed by 24 respondents from the general public of The Bahamas. Open-ended and closed questions were included, with perceptions scored using a Likert scale (1 = low welfare; 5 = high welfare). Differences in scores between levels of education and number of years experience with horses were analysed using independent t-tests (P<0.05). Qualitative data were analysed using thematic content analysis. Out of the 24 participants, 67% had prior experience with carriage horses, 25% had no experience and 8% were unsure. When asked to describe welfare, all respondents were found to show some understanding of the term welfare. The perception of welfare of these carriage horses was viewed negatively by the population; when rating the welfare of carriage horses, 83% scored 1 with none scoring above 3. When asked if participants felt that the use of carriage horses for tourism should continue all participants chose no (79%) or not sure (21%). Responses were not affected by education or equine experience. Results suggest that the participants from the general Bahamian public understood what welfare was and welfare needs were; validating concerns in the media. Research on carriage horses in general is lacking, while research I horses in the Bahamas is non-existent. Therefore further research is needed to determine the validity of these concerns to determine whether action needs to be taken to ensure positive welfare in these horses.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages44
    Number of pages1
    Publication statusPublished - May 2019
    Event9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference - Hartpury University, United Kingdom
    Duration: 8 May 20198 May 2019

    Conference

    Conference9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference
    CountryUnited Kingdom
    Period8/5/198/5/19

    Fingerprint

    tourism
    horses
    Bahamas
    educational status
    lameness
    laws and regulations
    body condition
    monkeys
    education
    questionnaires

    Cite this

    Lleida , A., & Greening, L. (2019). Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare. 44. Poster session presented at 9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference , United Kingdom.
    Lleida , Amber ; Greening, Linda. / Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare. Poster session presented at 9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference , United Kingdom.1 p.
    @conference{b535b3d00e6b4beb948fa9c7b8b901d1,
    title = "Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare",
    abstract = "Concern has been raised to the welfare of carriage pulling horses in terms of breeds used, the occurrence of lameness, poor body condition, the effects of heat and environmental stressors. There is also weak legislation surrounding the regulation of carriage horses. The aim of this study was to identify the Bahamian publics perception of welfare of carriage horses used for tourism in The Bahamas. Objectives included determining the Bahamian publics understanding of welfare and welfare needs, and whether perceptions were influenced by level of education or experience with horses. An online questionnaire made available via Survey monkey was completed by 24 respondents from the general public of The Bahamas. Open-ended and closed questions were included, with perceptions scored using a Likert scale (1 = low welfare; 5 = high welfare). Differences in scores between levels of education and number of years experience with horses were analysed using independent t-tests (P<0.05). Qualitative data were analysed using thematic content analysis. Out of the 24 participants, 67{\%} had prior experience with carriage horses, 25{\%} had no experience and 8{\%} were unsure. When asked to describe welfare, all respondents were found to show some understanding of the term welfare. The perception of welfare of these carriage horses was viewed negatively by the population; when rating the welfare of carriage horses, 83{\%} scored 1 with none scoring above 3. When asked if participants felt that the use of carriage horses for tourism should continue all participants chose no (79{\%}) or not sure (21{\%}). Responses were not affected by education or equine experience. Results suggest that the participants from the general Bahamian public understood what welfare was and welfare needs were; validating concerns in the media. Research on carriage horses in general is lacking, while research I horses in the Bahamas is non-existent. Therefore further research is needed to determine the validity of these concerns to determine whether action needs to be taken to ensure positive welfare in these horses.",
    author = "Amber Lleida and Linda Greening",
    year = "2019",
    month = "5",
    language = "English",
    pages = "44",
    note = "9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference ; Conference date: 08-05-2019 Through 08-05-2019",

    }

    Lleida , A & Greening, L 2019, 'Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare' 9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference , United Kingdom, 8/5/19 - 8/5/19, pp. 44.

    Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare. / Lleida , Amber; Greening, Linda.

    2019. 44 Poster session presented at 9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference , United Kingdom.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePoster

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare

    AU - Lleida , Amber

    AU - Greening, Linda

    PY - 2019/5

    Y1 - 2019/5

    N2 - Concern has been raised to the welfare of carriage pulling horses in terms of breeds used, the occurrence of lameness, poor body condition, the effects of heat and environmental stressors. There is also weak legislation surrounding the regulation of carriage horses. The aim of this study was to identify the Bahamian publics perception of welfare of carriage horses used for tourism in The Bahamas. Objectives included determining the Bahamian publics understanding of welfare and welfare needs, and whether perceptions were influenced by level of education or experience with horses. An online questionnaire made available via Survey monkey was completed by 24 respondents from the general public of The Bahamas. Open-ended and closed questions were included, with perceptions scored using a Likert scale (1 = low welfare; 5 = high welfare). Differences in scores between levels of education and number of years experience with horses were analysed using independent t-tests (P<0.05). Qualitative data were analysed using thematic content analysis. Out of the 24 participants, 67% had prior experience with carriage horses, 25% had no experience and 8% were unsure. When asked to describe welfare, all respondents were found to show some understanding of the term welfare. The perception of welfare of these carriage horses was viewed negatively by the population; when rating the welfare of carriage horses, 83% scored 1 with none scoring above 3. When asked if participants felt that the use of carriage horses for tourism should continue all participants chose no (79%) or not sure (21%). Responses were not affected by education or equine experience. Results suggest that the participants from the general Bahamian public understood what welfare was and welfare needs were; validating concerns in the media. Research on carriage horses in general is lacking, while research I horses in the Bahamas is non-existent. Therefore further research is needed to determine the validity of these concerns to determine whether action needs to be taken to ensure positive welfare in these horses.

    AB - Concern has been raised to the welfare of carriage pulling horses in terms of breeds used, the occurrence of lameness, poor body condition, the effects of heat and environmental stressors. There is also weak legislation surrounding the regulation of carriage horses. The aim of this study was to identify the Bahamian publics perception of welfare of carriage horses used for tourism in The Bahamas. Objectives included determining the Bahamian publics understanding of welfare and welfare needs, and whether perceptions were influenced by level of education or experience with horses. An online questionnaire made available via Survey monkey was completed by 24 respondents from the general public of The Bahamas. Open-ended and closed questions were included, with perceptions scored using a Likert scale (1 = low welfare; 5 = high welfare). Differences in scores between levels of education and number of years experience with horses were analysed using independent t-tests (P<0.05). Qualitative data were analysed using thematic content analysis. Out of the 24 participants, 67% had prior experience with carriage horses, 25% had no experience and 8% were unsure. When asked to describe welfare, all respondents were found to show some understanding of the term welfare. The perception of welfare of these carriage horses was viewed negatively by the population; when rating the welfare of carriage horses, 83% scored 1 with none scoring above 3. When asked if participants felt that the use of carriage horses for tourism should continue all participants chose no (79%) or not sure (21%). Responses were not affected by education or equine experience. Results suggest that the participants from the general Bahamian public understood what welfare was and welfare needs were; validating concerns in the media. Research on carriage horses in general is lacking, while research I horses in the Bahamas is non-existent. Therefore further research is needed to determine the validity of these concerns to determine whether action needs to be taken to ensure positive welfare in these horses.

    M3 - Poster

    SP - 44

    ER -

    Lleida A, Greening L. Investigating whether public perceptions of carriage driving for tourism recognises positive welfare. 2019. Poster session presented at 9th Alltech-Hartpury Student Conference , United Kingdom.