Pain expression is linked to personality in horses

Carrie Ijichi, Lisa M. Collins, Robert W. Elwood

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal Article

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Tissue damage may result in pain, inducing protective behaviour such as lameness. Because we cannot directly measure an animal's subjective experience, pain research and veterinary assessment rely on these behavioural indicators when quantifying pain. This assumes that pain expression is proportional to damage but this has not been tested in animals and ignores the possible effects of personality and coping style. First, we assessed whether lameness accurately predicted the severity of tissue damage, or whether there is variance in how "stoical" individuals are. An experienced equine veterinarian scored horses for lameness and then the severity of tissue damage using either x-ray or ultrasound during the course of normal diagnostics in a clinical setting. Contrary to assumptions, we found no relation between scores for lameness and severity. Consequently, "stoicism" was calculated as severity score minus lameness score. We tested hypotheses founded on previous work concerning how personality would be expected to link with stoicism and pain behaviour. Personality was quantified using a validated questionnaire, completed by owners. Owners also gave their subjective opinion on how tolerant the horse was to pain using a 1-5 likert scale. This is the first paper to assess the relationships between pain behaviour and personality in animals. We found that neuroticism is negatively related to "stoicism" whereas extroversion was positively related to levels of lameness, which may mean that pain in more easily identified in highly extrovert individuals. Future work to clarify these findings and their major implications for accurate assessment of damage and pain in animals are discussed. ?? 2013 Elsevier B.V.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)38-43
Number of pages6
JournalApplied Animal Behaviour Science
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2014
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Horses
Personality
pain
horses
Pain
lameness
animals
Veterinarians
Pain Measurement
veterinarians
X-Rays
X-radiation
questionnaires
Research
tissues

Keywords

  • Coping
  • Extroversion
  • Lameness
  • Neuroticism
  • Pain
  • Personality

Cite this

Ijichi, Carrie ; Collins, Lisa M. ; Elwood, Robert W. / Pain expression is linked to personality in horses. In: Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 2014 ; pp. 38-43.
@article{f8e27473be23457bbd644a6e0a0c3902,
title = "Pain expression is linked to personality in horses",
abstract = "Tissue damage may result in pain, inducing protective behaviour such as lameness. Because we cannot directly measure an animal's subjective experience, pain research and veterinary assessment rely on these behavioural indicators when quantifying pain. This assumes that pain expression is proportional to damage but this has not been tested in animals and ignores the possible effects of personality and coping style. First, we assessed whether lameness accurately predicted the severity of tissue damage, or whether there is variance in how {"}stoical{"} individuals are. An experienced equine veterinarian scored horses for lameness and then the severity of tissue damage using either x-ray or ultrasound during the course of normal diagnostics in a clinical setting. Contrary to assumptions, we found no relation between scores for lameness and severity. Consequently, {"}stoicism{"} was calculated as severity score minus lameness score. We tested hypotheses founded on previous work concerning how personality would be expected to link with stoicism and pain behaviour. Personality was quantified using a validated questionnaire, completed by owners. Owners also gave their subjective opinion on how tolerant the horse was to pain using a 1-5 likert scale. This is the first paper to assess the relationships between pain behaviour and personality in animals. We found that neuroticism is negatively related to {"}stoicism{"} whereas extroversion was positively related to levels of lameness, which may mean that pain in more easily identified in highly extrovert individuals. Future work to clarify these findings and their major implications for accurate assessment of damage and pain in animals are discussed. ?? 2013 Elsevier B.V.",
keywords = "Coping, Extroversion, Lameness, Neuroticism, Pain, Personality",
author = "Carrie Ijichi and Collins, {Lisa M.} and Elwood, {Robert W.}",
year = "2014",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1016/j.applanim.2013.12.007",
language = "English",
pages = "38--43",
journal = "Applied Animal Behaviour Science",
issn = "0168-1591",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Pain expression is linked to personality in horses. / Ijichi, Carrie; Collins, Lisa M.; Elwood, Robert W.

In: Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 03.2014, p. 38-43.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal Article

TY - JOUR

T1 - Pain expression is linked to personality in horses

AU - Ijichi, Carrie

AU - Collins, Lisa M.

AU - Elwood, Robert W.

PY - 2014/3

Y1 - 2014/3

N2 - Tissue damage may result in pain, inducing protective behaviour such as lameness. Because we cannot directly measure an animal's subjective experience, pain research and veterinary assessment rely on these behavioural indicators when quantifying pain. This assumes that pain expression is proportional to damage but this has not been tested in animals and ignores the possible effects of personality and coping style. First, we assessed whether lameness accurately predicted the severity of tissue damage, or whether there is variance in how "stoical" individuals are. An experienced equine veterinarian scored horses for lameness and then the severity of tissue damage using either x-ray or ultrasound during the course of normal diagnostics in a clinical setting. Contrary to assumptions, we found no relation between scores for lameness and severity. Consequently, "stoicism" was calculated as severity score minus lameness score. We tested hypotheses founded on previous work concerning how personality would be expected to link with stoicism and pain behaviour. Personality was quantified using a validated questionnaire, completed by owners. Owners also gave their subjective opinion on how tolerant the horse was to pain using a 1-5 likert scale. This is the first paper to assess the relationships between pain behaviour and personality in animals. We found that neuroticism is negatively related to "stoicism" whereas extroversion was positively related to levels of lameness, which may mean that pain in more easily identified in highly extrovert individuals. Future work to clarify these findings and their major implications for accurate assessment of damage and pain in animals are discussed. ?? 2013 Elsevier B.V.

AB - Tissue damage may result in pain, inducing protective behaviour such as lameness. Because we cannot directly measure an animal's subjective experience, pain research and veterinary assessment rely on these behavioural indicators when quantifying pain. This assumes that pain expression is proportional to damage but this has not been tested in animals and ignores the possible effects of personality and coping style. First, we assessed whether lameness accurately predicted the severity of tissue damage, or whether there is variance in how "stoical" individuals are. An experienced equine veterinarian scored horses for lameness and then the severity of tissue damage using either x-ray or ultrasound during the course of normal diagnostics in a clinical setting. Contrary to assumptions, we found no relation between scores for lameness and severity. Consequently, "stoicism" was calculated as severity score minus lameness score. We tested hypotheses founded on previous work concerning how personality would be expected to link with stoicism and pain behaviour. Personality was quantified using a validated questionnaire, completed by owners. Owners also gave their subjective opinion on how tolerant the horse was to pain using a 1-5 likert scale. This is the first paper to assess the relationships between pain behaviour and personality in animals. We found that neuroticism is negatively related to "stoicism" whereas extroversion was positively related to levels of lameness, which may mean that pain in more easily identified in highly extrovert individuals. Future work to clarify these findings and their major implications for accurate assessment of damage and pain in animals are discussed. ?? 2013 Elsevier B.V.

KW - Coping

KW - Extroversion

KW - Lameness

KW - Neuroticism

KW - Pain

KW - Personality

U2 - 10.1016/j.applanim.2013.12.007

DO - 10.1016/j.applanim.2013.12.007

M3 - Journal Article

SP - 38

EP - 43

JO - Applied Animal Behaviour Science

JF - Applied Animal Behaviour Science

SN - 0168-1591

ER -