When winning is not enough: learning through reflections on the ‘best‐self’

Tony Ghaye, Sarah Lee, Daniel J. Shaw, Gavin Chesterfield

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal Article

Abstract

This paper explores the view that, for some, it is not enough simply to win, but to win with integrity and care. This is linked with the idea of the reflected best-self (RBS) and RBS portraits are illustrated with short narratives from football, netball and equine sport. It is suggested that the notion of the RBS and its (re)construction adds something new and different to the principles and processes of reflective learning. The point is made that any use of narratives requires those involved to develop their narrative intelligence. The dynamic nature of RBS portraits, and in particular their (re)construction, is explained with reference to 'thin-slicing' and to the impact of four types of 'jolt'. Latterly, it is suggested that, at the coach-athlete level, there is a clear need to place high quality connections (HQC's) at the heart of improving performance. Supportive of this is a commitment to accentuate the positive in any process of learning through reflection. One implication of the issues raised in this paper is that coach education may have to let go of some of its silo practices and build new and creative bridges across different arenas of scholarship.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)385-401
Number of pages17
JournalReflective Practice
Volume10
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 14 Jul 2009

Fingerprint

Self-portrait
Education
Reflective Learning
Integrity
Football
Athletes
Silo

Cite this

Ghaye, Tony ; Lee, Sarah ; Shaw, Daniel J. ; Chesterfield, Gavin. / When winning is not enough: learning through reflections on the ‘best‐self’. In: Reflective Practice. 2009 ; Vol. 10, No. 3. pp. 385-401.
@article{8a360445204149448f37812b1de0f854,
title = "When winning is not enough: learning through reflections on the ‘best‐self’",
abstract = "This paper explores the view that, for some, it is not enough simply to win, but to win with integrity and care. This is linked with the idea of the reflected best-self (RBS) and RBS portraits are illustrated with short narratives from football, netball and equine sport. It is suggested that the notion of the RBS and its (re)construction adds something new and different to the principles and processes of reflective learning. The point is made that any use of narratives requires those involved to develop their narrative intelligence. The dynamic nature of RBS portraits, and in particular their (re)construction, is explained with reference to 'thin-slicing' and to the impact of four types of 'jolt'. Latterly, it is suggested that, at the coach-athlete level, there is a clear need to place high quality connections (HQC's) at the heart of improving performance. Supportive of this is a commitment to accentuate the positive in any process of learning through reflection. One implication of the issues raised in this paper is that coach education may have to let go of some of its silo practices and build new and creative bridges across different arenas of scholarship.",
author = "Tony Ghaye and Sarah Lee and Shaw, {Daniel J.} and Gavin Chesterfield",
year = "2009",
month = "7",
day = "14",
doi = "10.1080/14623940903034747",
language = "English",
volume = "10",
pages = "385--401",
journal = "Reflective Practice",
issn = "1462-3943",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "3",

}

When winning is not enough: learning through reflections on the ‘best‐self’. / Ghaye, Tony; Lee, Sarah; Shaw, Daniel J.; Chesterfield, Gavin.

In: Reflective Practice, Vol. 10, No. 3, 14.07.2009, p. 385-401.

Research output: Contribution to journalJournal Article

TY - JOUR

T1 - When winning is not enough: learning through reflections on the ‘best‐self’

AU - Ghaye, Tony

AU - Lee, Sarah

AU - Shaw, Daniel J.

AU - Chesterfield, Gavin

PY - 2009/7/14

Y1 - 2009/7/14

N2 - This paper explores the view that, for some, it is not enough simply to win, but to win with integrity and care. This is linked with the idea of the reflected best-self (RBS) and RBS portraits are illustrated with short narratives from football, netball and equine sport. It is suggested that the notion of the RBS and its (re)construction adds something new and different to the principles and processes of reflective learning. The point is made that any use of narratives requires those involved to develop their narrative intelligence. The dynamic nature of RBS portraits, and in particular their (re)construction, is explained with reference to 'thin-slicing' and to the impact of four types of 'jolt'. Latterly, it is suggested that, at the coach-athlete level, there is a clear need to place high quality connections (HQC's) at the heart of improving performance. Supportive of this is a commitment to accentuate the positive in any process of learning through reflection. One implication of the issues raised in this paper is that coach education may have to let go of some of its silo practices and build new and creative bridges across different arenas of scholarship.

AB - This paper explores the view that, for some, it is not enough simply to win, but to win with integrity and care. This is linked with the idea of the reflected best-self (RBS) and RBS portraits are illustrated with short narratives from football, netball and equine sport. It is suggested that the notion of the RBS and its (re)construction adds something new and different to the principles and processes of reflective learning. The point is made that any use of narratives requires those involved to develop their narrative intelligence. The dynamic nature of RBS portraits, and in particular their (re)construction, is explained with reference to 'thin-slicing' and to the impact of four types of 'jolt'. Latterly, it is suggested that, at the coach-athlete level, there is a clear need to place high quality connections (HQC's) at the heart of improving performance. Supportive of this is a commitment to accentuate the positive in any process of learning through reflection. One implication of the issues raised in this paper is that coach education may have to let go of some of its silo practices and build new and creative bridges across different arenas of scholarship.

U2 - 10.1080/14623940903034747

DO - 10.1080/14623940903034747

M3 - Journal Article

VL - 10

SP - 385

EP - 401

JO - Reflective Practice

JF - Reflective Practice

SN - 1462-3943

IS - 3

ER -